| Show | Year | Director | Category |
| Shakespeare at the Ruins: As You Like It | 2022 | Holdren | Shakespeare |
| It Shoulda Been You | 2022 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| Winter Break | 2022 | Sauls | Teen Arts Project (TAP) |
| It's a Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play | 2021 | Moran | Holiday |
| All in the Timing | 2021 | Hogan | Comedy |
| Back to Barboursville: The Terri Allard Trio | 2021 | Allard | Concert |
| Beginning to See the Light | 2021 | Wayne | Musical Revue |
| The Laramie Project | 2021 | Medlin | (Virtual) Drama |
| Student Council V. Andi Johnson | 2021 | Mabie | (Virtual) Teen Arts Project (TAP) Comedy |
| Home for the Holidays | 2020 | E. Warwick White | (Virtual) Musical Revue |
| Help Desk: A Stay-At-Home-Play | 2020 | Thomas | (Virtual) Comedy |
| The Mousetrap | 2020 | Johnston | Drama |
| Dear Edwina | 2020 | Sauls | Teen Arts Project Musical |
| Irving Berlin's White Christmas | 2019 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| The Savannah Sipping Society | 2019 | Hoover | Comedy |
| Shakespeare at the Ruins: A Midsummer Night's Dream | 2019 | Horan | Shakespeare |
| God of Carnage | 2019 | Thomas | Drama |
| Hello, Dolly! | 2019 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| Songs in the Cellar: Broadway Our Way: A Teen Musical Revue | 2019 | Sauls | Revue |
| The Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 2018 | Gargett | Children's |
| The Lion in Winter | 2018 | Johnston | Drama |
| Young Frankenstein | 2018 | Medlin | Musical |
| Avenue Q | 2018 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| Noises Off | 2018 | Pedersen | Comedy |
| Songs in the Cellar: A View From Some Broads | 2018 | Zuby | Musical Revue |
| A Christmas Story: The Musical | 2017 | Sauls | Musical |
| The Crucible | 2017 | Gray | Drama |
| The Best of Barboursville | 2017 | E. Warwick White & Schaper | Musical Revue |
| The Addams Family | 2017 | Bastian | Musical |
| Blithe Spirit | 2017 | Susen | Comedy |
| Dancing With Myself | 2017 | Harris | Teen Arts Project |
| Chicago | 2017 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| Love Letters | 2017 | Zuby | Drama |
| A Charlie Brown Christmas | 2016 | Gargett | Children's |
| Bullet For Unaccompanied Heart | 2016 | Moore | Drama |
| Once On This Island | 2016 | Kristel | Musical |
| The Great American Trailer Park Musical | 2016 | Zuby/G. Warwick White | Musical |
| Moon Over Buffalo | 2016 | Lowrance | Comedy |
| Songs in the Cellar: Broadway by the Decade: The 1990s | 2016 | Gargett | Revue |
| HONK! | 2015 | Sauls | Musical |
| Macbeth | 2015 | Gray | Drama |
| An Evening of Big Band to Build a Backstage | 2015 | Mallek | Concert |
| The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | 2015 | Bastian | Musical |
| Our Town | 2015 | Pedersen | Drama |
| The Fantasticks | 2015 | E. Warwick White | Musical |
| Songs in the Cellar: Broadway by the Decade: The 1960s | 2015 | Sauls | Revue |
| Little Women | 2014 | Susen | Drama |
| Black Comedy | 2014 | Horst | Comedy |
| Broadway's Sparkling Diamonds & Hidden Gems | 2014 | Sauls | Revue |
| SHREK: The Musical | 2014 | St. Ours | Musical |
| Bedroom Farce | 2014 | Davis | Comedy |
| Bye Bye Birdie | 2014 | Sauls | Musical |
| Dirty Barbie & Other Girlhood Tales (Denise Stewart) | 2014 | Stewart/Nedzel | Original |
| Songs in the Cellar: Backwards Broadway | 2014 | E. Warwick White | Revue |
| A Christmas Carol | 2013 | Boggs/Susen | Children's |
| The Fourth Wall | 2013 | Waller | Comedy |
| Terri Allard Hosts Songwriters in the Round | 2013 | N/A | Concert |
| Godspell | 2013 | Bastian | Musical |
| The Taming of the Shrew | 2013 | Franklin-Heiderstadt | Shakespeare |
| Into the Woods | 2013 | Boggs | Musical |
| Sixteen in 10 Minutes or Less | 2013 | Mawyer/Sauls | Comedy |
| The Homecoming | 2012 | DeAngeles/Lowrance | Children's |
| Woman in a Tiled Room | 2012 | Smith | Drama |
| 40 and Fabulous | 2012 | Sauls/Boggs | Revue |
| I Love You Because | 2012 | Boggs/Warwick White | Musical |
| Snoopy!!! | 2012 | Zuby | Musical |
| Stepping Out | 2012 | Sauls | Comedy |
| The Food Chain | 2012 | Boggs | Comedy |
| Scarlet Pimpernel | 2012 | Davis | Musical |
| Well-Adjusted | 2012 | Moore | Comedy |
| It's A Wonderful Life | 2011 | Cutshaw | Children's |
| Broadway Then and Now | 2011 | Sauls | Revue |
| Endgame | 2011 | Spangler | Drama |
| Robin Hood: The Musical | 2011 | Bertaux | Musical |
| Importance of Being Earnest | 2011 | Holdren | Comedy |
| Annie | 2011 | Sauls | Musical |
| Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 2010 | Sauls | Children's |
| A Taste of Modern Broadway | 2010 | Hart/Boggs | Revue |
| Tempest | 2010 | Holdren | Shakespeare |
| Alice in Wonderland | 2010 | Bastian | Musical |
| Sylvia | 2010 | Waller | Comedy |
| Song of Mark | 2010 | Belan | Concert |
| Cabaret | 2010 | Spangler | Musical |
| Doubles | 2010 | Sauls | Comedy |
| Mafia on Prozac | 2009 | Boggs | Comedy |
| Oliver! | 2009 | Boggs | Musical |
| Same Time Next Year | 2009 | DeAngeles | Comedy |
| The Adventures of Tom Sawyer | 2009 | Richardson | Musical |
| Hamlet | 2009 | Lucia | Shakespeare |
| A Christmas Story | 2009 | Thomas/Bush | Children's |
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat | 2008 | DeAngeles | Musical |
| Lend Me A Tenor | 2008 | Waller | Comedy |
| Looking Glass Alley | 2008 | Van Houzen | Original |
| A Christmas Carol | 2008 | Johnston | Drama |
| As You Like it | 2008 | Holdren | Shakespeare |
| Othello | 2008 | Johnston | Shakespeare |
| Company | 2007 | Smith | Musical |
| The Little Theater that Could - 35th Anniversary Revue | 2007 | Smith | Revue |
| The Velveteen Rabbit | 2007 | Lambert | Children's |
| Twelfth Night | 2007 | Holdren | Shakespeare |
| Book of Liz | 2007 | McCarthy | Comedy |
| Miracle on 34th Street | 2007 | Locke | Children's |
| Boy Gets Girl | 2006 | Prine | Drama |
| Babes in Arms | 2006 | Locke | Musical |
| Come Back to the 5 and Dime - Jimmy Dean | 2006 | Smith | Drama |
| All's Well That Ends Well | 2006 | Johnston | Shakespeare |
| 1776 | 2005 | Davis | Musical |
| A Midsummer Night's Dream | 2005 | St. Ours | Shakespeare |
| Harvey | 2005 | Goldstein | Comedy |
| Lightly Seasoned | 2005 | Prine | Drama |
| The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe | 2005 | Beatty | Children's |
| Doug Schneider and Friends | 2004 | Schneider | Concert |
| Irish Music Festival | 2004 | Prine | Concert |
| Beauty Queen of Leenane | 2004 | Sackett Smith | Drama |
| Music Man | 2004 | Roberts | Musical |
| They're Playing Our Song | 2004 | Ellis | Musical |
| Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 2004 | Thorpe | Children's |
| Much Ado About Nothing | 2004 | Gonzalez | Shakespeare |
| Love's Labour's Lost | 2003 | Tucker | Shakespeare |
| Once Upon a Mattress | 2003 | Packard | Musical |
| Spring Music Festival - Battle of the Bands | 2003 | Foster/Frisch | Concert/Competition |
| Steel Magnolias | 2003 | Ohleger | Drama |
| The Hobbit | 2003 | Belan | Children's |
| Brighton Beach Memoirs | 2003 | Morris | Drama |
| Little Women | 2002 | Canevari | Drama |
| Man of La Mancha | 2002 | Yemington | Musical |
| Schoolhouse Rock Jr. | 2002 | Harris-Pentz | Children's Camp |
| Thirty Years and Counting | 2002 | Ellis | Revue |
| Comedy of Errors | 2002 | Horan | Shakespeare |
| You're a Good Man Charlie Brown | 2002 | Yemmington | Musical |
| Christmas Carol | 2001 | Thomas | Children's |
| Into the Woods Jr. | 2001 | Dukes/Nicoll | Children's Camp |
| Mame | 2001 | Fogiani | Musical |
| Play it Again Sam | 2001 | McFadden | Comedy |
| Two Gentlemen of Verona | 2001 | Roy | Shakespeare |
| Diary of Anne Frank | 2001 | Watkins | Drama |
| Comedy of Errors Scenes | 2000 | Dukes/Nicoll | Children's Camp |
| Lollipops and Roses | 2000 | Clements | Revue |
| Nutcracker Ballet | 2000 | Horan/Porter | Children's |
| Secret Garden | 2000 | Belan | Musical |
| Taming of the Shrew | 2000 | Coy | Shakespeare |
| Closer than Ever | 2000 | Sackett-Smith | Musical |
| Moon Over Buffalo | 2000 | McFadden | Comedy |
| Oklahoma | 1999 | Ellis | Musical |
| Taking Steps | 1999 | Davis | Comedy |
| Workshops | 1999 | Dukes | Children's Camp |
| Merry Wives of Windsor | 1999 | Cohen | Shakespeare |
| Polka Dots and Moonbeams | 1999 | Clements | Revue |
| Christmas Carol | 1999 | Thomas | Children's |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 1998 | Watkins | Musical |
| Foxfire | 1998 | Fuller | Drama |
| Midsummer Night's Dream | 1998 | Horan | Shakespeare |
| Barefoot in the Park | 1998 | Fuller | Comedy |
| Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 1998 | Brookman | Children's |
| Greater Tune | 1997 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Little Shop of Horrors | 1997 | Locke | Musical |
| Music in You - R&H Revue | 1997 | Wagner | Revue |
| Really Rosie | 1997 | Belan | Children's |
| Romeo and Juliet | 1997 | Horan | Shakespeare |
| Sisters Rosensweig | 1997 | Ohleger | Comedy |
| Folk Concert - 25th Anniversary | 1997 | Prine | Concert |
| Camelot | 1997 | Faust | Musical |
| Embraceable You | 1996 | Locke | Revue |
| Little Night Music | 1996 | Davis | Musical |
| Music of the Night | 1996 | Collins | Revue |
| Rumors | 1996 | Belan | Comedy |
| Tempest | 1996 | Fuller | Shakespeare |
| What I Did Last Summer | 1996 | Horan | Comedy |
| Anne of Greene Gables | 1996 | McRaven | Children's |
| Homecoming | 1995 | Roberts | Children's |
| Best of Barboursville II | 1995 | Ramsey | Revue |
| Quilters | 1995 | Cummings | Musical |
| Symphony of Light | 1995 | Berry | Magic |
| Unexpected Guest | 1995 | Anson | Drama |
| When You Wish Upon a Star | 1995 | Anson | Revue |
| Winter's Tale | 1995 | Smith | Shakespeare |
| Little Foxes | 1995 | McClendon | Drama |
| As You Like It | 1994 | Muchmore | Shakespeare |
| Narnia | 1994 | Burns | Children's |
| Arsenic and Old Lace | 1994 | Lrrick | Drama |
| Evita | 1994 | Davis | Musical |
| Crimes of the Heart | 1993 | Price | Comedy |
| Into the Woods | 1993 | Ward | Comedy |
| Laura | 1993 | Ramsey | Drama |
| Much Ado About Nothing | 1993 | Smith | Shakespeare |
| Woman of Influence | 1993 | Faust- P | One Act |
| Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 1993 | Purcell | Children's |
| How the Grinch Stole Chrismas | 1992 | Brookman | Children's |
| Twelfth Night | 1992 | Smith | Shakespeare |
| Godspell | 1992 | Davis | Musical |
| You Can't Take it With You | 1992 | Burr | Comedy |
| Importance of Being Earnest | 1992 | Faust | Comedy |
| Night Hank Williams Died | 1991 | Ramsey | Drama |
| Night of the Iguana | 1991 | Price | Drama |
| Best Christmas Pageant Ever | 1991 | Brookman | Children's |
| Taming of the Shrew | 1991 | Smith | Shakespeare |
| Steel Magnolias | 1991 | Robinson | Drama |
| Chapter Two | 1990 | Meyer | Comedy |
| Deathtrap | 1990 | Ramsey | Drama |
| Midsummer Night's Dream | 1990 | Smith | Shakespeare |
| Phantom Tollbooth | 1990 | Feathers | Children's |
| Betrothal | 1989 | Shur | One Act |
| Chinamen | 1989 | Davis | One Act |
| Five Finger Exercise | 1989 | Crissman | Drama |
| Flower Drum Song | 1989 | Viemeister | Musical |
| Graceland | 1989 | Wright | One Act |
| Heartbreak House | 1989 | Smith | Drama |
| Jim & Jesse | 1989 | Faust | Concert |
| Many Moons | 1989 | Viemeister | Children's |
| Sandbox | 1989 | Blackwell | One Act |
| Light Up the Sky | 1988 | Rhinelander | Comedy |
| Oliver! | 1988 | Owen/Smith | Musical |
| Tinytypes | 1988 | Wagner | Musical |
| Wake of Jamey Foster | 1988 | Sackett | Drama |
| Really Rosie | 1988 | Audibert | Children's |
| Annie Get Your Gun | 1987 | Niebel | Musical |
| Barbar Mahler Dance Theater | 1987 | N/A | Dance |
| Evening of Dance (B. Mahler) | 1987 | Mahler | Dance |
| Grandpa's Birthday | 1987 | Parent | Stories |
| Member of the Wedding | 1987 | Prine | Drama |
| Mousetrap | 1987 | Glimidakis - Lyne | Drama |
| On Golden Pond | 1987 | Faust | Drama |
| We the People | 1987 | Faust | Drama |
| Wizard of Oz | 1987 | Thomas | Children's |
| Actors Support Fund Benefit Concert | 1987 | N/A | Concert |
| Belie of Amherst | 1987 | Sackett | Drama |
| Constant Wife | 1986 | Lewis | Comedy |
| Same Time, Next Year | 1986 | Bethea | Comedy |
| Lady's Not for Burning | 1986 | Sackett | Drama |
| Preferential Treatment | 1986 | Various | One Act |
| Bluegrass Concert | 1986 | Boucher | Concert |
| Sound of Music | 1986 | Bethea | Musical |
| Action with Fashion | 1986 | Thomas | Fashion Show |
| Folk Concert | 1986 | N/A | Concert |
| Grease | 1985 | Thomas | Musical |
| Hansel and Gretel | 1985 | Fogliani | Children's |
| My Fair Lady | 1985 | Faust | Musical |
| Night of January 16th | 1985 | Thomas | Drama |
| Christmas Carol (@Exchange Hotel) | 1985 | Morse | Children's |
| Folk Concert | 1985 | Morris | Concert |
| Fables for Friends | 1984 | Rives | Children's |
| Folk Concert | 1984 | N/A | Concert |
| Toys in the Attic | 1984 | Sackett | Drama |
| Blithe Spirit | 1984 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Come Back Little Sheba | 1984 | Crickenberger | Drama |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 1983 | Thomas | Musical |
| Tom Jones | 1983 | Sackett | Comedy |
| Clown who Ran Away | 1983 | Robinson | Children's |
| Best of Barboursville | 1982 | Faust | Rev |
| Anastasia | 1982 | Allard | Drama |
| Chicago | 1982 | Sackett-Tree | Musical |
| Come Blow Your Horn | 1982 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Cosmology | 1982 | NA | Concert |
| Folk Concert - Annual Benefit | 1982 | Wheaton | Concert |
| Folk Concert - Incredible Sounds | 1982 | N/A | Concert |
| Funny Girl | 1982 | Venneloweth | Musical |
| John Jackson | 1982 | NA | Concert |
| Length of Childhood | 1982 | Nash | Dance |
| McGuffey Dance | 1982 | N/A | Dance |
| Me Nobody Knows | 1982 | Thomas - Tree | Drama |
| Sally Nash's Last Minute Wood Company | 1982 | Nash | Dance |
| Velveteen Rabbit | 1982 | Fogliani | Children's |
| Working | 1982 | Sackett - Tree | Drama |
| Bus Stop | 1982 | Watts | Drama |
| My Cup Runneth Over | 1981 | deSandro | One Act |
| Annie | 1981 | Fogliani | Musical |
| Date of Bobby Sax | 1981 | Simmons | One Act |
| Delicate Balance | 1981 | Ramsey | Drama |
| Evening of Comedy | 1981 | Various | One Act |
| Folk Concert | 1981 | Audibert | Concert |
| Happy Journey to Camden and Trenton | 1981 | Beatty | One Act |
| Moon Children | 1981 | Tree | Drama |
| Clumsy Custard Horror Show | 1981 | Thomas - Tree | Children's |
| Nutcracker | 1981 | Unknown | Children's |
| Runaways | 1981 | Sackett - Tree | Drama |
| Somewhat Sill Saturday | 1981 | Parent | Stories/Mime |
| Still Alarm | 1981 | Simmons | One Act |
| Uncle Vanya | 1981 | Faust | Drama |
| West Side Story | 1981 | Thomas | Musical |
| Cloud Valley | 1981 | NA | Concert |
| Cactus Flower | 1980 | Audibert | Comedy |
| Dark of the Moon | 1980 | Thomas - Tree | Drama |
| Don't Drink the Water | 1980 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Flowers for Algemon | 1980 | Venneloweth | Drama |
| Folk Concert | 1980 | N/A | Concert |
| House at Pooh Corner | 1980 | Fogliani | Children's |
| King and I | 1980 | Thomas | Musical |
| Pigman | 1980 | Morris - Tree | Drama |
| Wait Until Dark | 1980 | Prine | Drama |
| Real Inspector Hount | 1979 | Straley | One Act |
| Ain't Misbehavin | 1979 | Sackett-Tree | Musical |
| Cabaret | 1979 | Thomas | Musical |
| Date | 1979 | Cook | One Act |
| Eveing of One Acts | 1979 | Various | One Act |
| Faint Voices | 1979 | Matthews | One Act |
| Gathering Together | 1979 | Nash | Dance |
| Hello from Bertha | 1979 | Stevens | One Act |
| How the Grinch Stole Chrismas | 1979 | Sackett - Tree | Children's |
| Jimmy Shine | 1979 | Kamrass - Tree | Drama |
| Lemonade | 1979 | Schoolcraft | One Act |
| Lord's Will | 1979 | Beatty | One Act |
| Man for All Seasons | 1979 | Stevens | Drama |
| Miracle Worker | 1979 | Faust | Drama |
| Appointment at 4 O'Clock | 1979 | Tree | One Act |
| Seven Dreams and an Awakening | 1979 | Nash | Dance |
| Summer One Acts | 1979 | Various | One Act |
| They'd Hang You in Nashville | 1979 | Sackett - Tree | Drama |
| Valiant | 1979 | Allard | One Act |
| You're a Good Man Charlie Brown | 1979 | Thomas | Musical |
| Alice in Wonderland | 1979 | Tyler/Bagby | Children's |
| Barefoot in the Park | 1978 | Audibert | Comedy |
| Carnival | 1978 | Thomas | Musical |
| Dracula Baby | 1978 | Sackett - Tree | Comedy |
| Folk Concert | 1978 | N/A | Concert |
| Of Mice and Men | 1978 | Allard | Drama |
| Sorry, Wrong Number | 1978 | Sackett | One Act |
| Stingy Mister Pennypincher | 1978 | Thomas | Children's |
| Ten Little Indians | 1978 | Thomas | Drama |
| Bremen Town Musicians | 1977 | Thomas | Children's |
| Forty Carats | 1977 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Mame | 1977 | Thomas | Musical |
| Marvelous Adventures of Tyl | 1977 | Thomas | Children's |
| Music Man | 1977 | Morse | Musical |
| Musical Evening | 1977 | Thomas | Revue |
| Picnic | 1977 | Morse | Drama |
| Take Away the Lady | 1977 | Waynesboro HS | Musical |
| Four Fathers | 1976 | Audibert | Drama |
| Great Cross Country Race | 1976 | Thomas | Children's |
| Male Animal | 1976 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Night of the Iguana | 1976 | Thomas | Drama |
| Once Upon a Mattress | 1976 | Thomas | Musical |
| Punch and Politics | 1976 | Audibert | Drama |
| Tom Sawyer | 1976 | Wagner | Children's |
| Yeomen of the Guard | 1976 | Greene/Morse | Musical |
| You Can't Take it With You | 1976 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Godspell | 1976 | Thomas | Musical |
| An Inspector Calls | 1975 | Beatty | Drama |
| Bad Seed | 1975 | Grigsby | Drama |
| I am Man, I am Woman | 1975 | Morse - Mini | One Act |
| Jack Jouett's Ride | 1975 | Royce | Drama |
| Land of the Fragon | 1975 | Thomas | Children's |
| Look Homeward Angel | 1975 | Grigsby | Drama |
| The Odd Couple | 1975 | Grigsby | Comedy |
| Oliver! | 1975 | Thomas | Musical |
| Tartuffe | 1975 | Thomas | comedy |
| Tivoli Circus | 1975 | Unknown | Circus |
| Cheaper by the Dozen | 1974 | Thomas | Children's |
| Effect of Gamma Rays onÂ… | 1974 | Grigsby | Drama |
| Gypsy | 1974 | Thomas | Comedy |
| Harvey | 1974 | Wagner | Comedy |
| Hobbitt | 1974 | Thomas | Children's |
| Livin de Life | 1974 | Thomas | Children's |
| Crucible | 1974 | Thomas | Drama |
| Christmas Carol | 1973 | Thomas | Musical |
| Dark Tower | 1973 | Thomas | One Act |
| Little Foxes | 1973 | Thomas | Drama |
| Mixed Media Evening | 1973 | Smith | Dance |
| Noah's Flood | 1973 | Morse | Children's |
| Stingy Mister Pennypincher | 1973 | Thomas | Children's |
| Switched at the Crossroads | 1973 | Morse | Drama |
| Don't Stop Till You Get Enough | 1960 | Sackett - Tree | Musical |
